A Controversial Issue

December 2001, Volume 40 No. 1
In the medal world at least the year 2001 will perhaps be best remembered for one issue – the award or rather non-award of certain medals. Quite naturally in this fiftieth anniversary year the Suez campaign medal or lack thereof has dominated the news but as we draw to the end of 2001 and the beginning of 2002 with that issue still unresolved yet another controversy comes to the fore. February 7 2002 is the fiftieth anniversary of Her Majesty the Queen’s accession to the throne, it is the Golden Jubilee, and with that event, as with other Jubilees before it, comes the award of a medal to be worn by at least some of those who have served Her Majesty in her time as monarch. However, as with other such awards just who those lucky enough to receive this medal will be is a matter of high debate and whilst in terms of numbers the Golden Jubilee medal looks set to be the most generous there are many who are unhappy with the allocation.

For Victoria’s Golden Jubilee most medals were awarded to high-ranking officials, foreign dignitaries, senior ministers etc with the only forces recipients being those Officers and a few NCOs who took part in the Jubilee parade of June 21 1887. The 1897 Medal had similar allocations with only 4,003 medals awarded in total of which only 980 went to the army and then only to Officers. The 1935 Silver Jubilee of King George V saw more medals awarded (some 85,000+) but these were again distributed far and wide to “the Great and Good of the Empire”, the Empire was back then still huge and 85,000 medals did not stretch very far leaving thousands of service men and women, many of whom had fought in World War I for “King and Country” who were sorely aggrieved at being overlooked. The next Jubilee, the present Queen’s Silver in 1977 again saw an allocation of thousands of medals (30,000 general issue and 30,000 Canadian issue) but again this was never going to be enough to please everybody and there was great controversy surrounding the award particularly in relation to the numbers awarded to the Armed Forces and the Emergency services. So it was that when the announcement was made that the new medal would be awarded far more generously there was hope at last that all those who deserved recognition would get it, it was at first thought that perhaps all those serving at the time of the jubilee would be presented with a medal but that rumour was quickly squashed and it was announced that only those in active service on February 7 2002 who had completed five or more years in one of the Armed Forces would qualify, and even then that was the minimum qualification and such service still did not guarantee anything. Although ostensibly a little harsh it can be seen why doling out medals to everyone serving would not be desirable, after all this medal is a recognition of service and to award it to everyone is to devalue it, one of the complaints about the 1977 medal was that it was in many quarters awarded too liberally, however when it is realised that, at least at the time of going to press, there are no plans at all to make this award available to anyone in the Fire, Police or Ambulance services and that if they wish to receive any such decoration at all it must be a purchased “unofficial” one it can be seen why once again controversy surrounds the issue of a Jubilee medal.

Order Back Issue

You can order this item as a back issue, simply select a delivery option from the list below and add it to your shopping basket. The price displayed is the cost of the magazine and the delivery combined.

Free Trial Issue
Click Here
A Controversial Issue
Free trial issue Subscribe Buy this back issue

In This Issue

Shadows cast on glittering Medal by Ashley Tinson
Rules and Regulations for awards
Research File20
A Mutiny Mystery by Geoff Wild
Search for a medal entitlement
The Royal Marines and the Second Boer War by Micheal Pinchen
An often-overlooked corps
Nicholson's Nek by David Humphrey
A disastrous defeat
Medal Roll28
The Rifle Brigade and the Indian Mutiny by George Caldwell
A little-known Camel Corps
Feature Article32
Duelling with the Kamikaze by Dave George
On board HMAS Australia in WWII
An Heroic Beaufighter crew by Mark Young
Veterans of WWII air combat
In Memoriam39
To finally rest in peace by Jim Grant
A Beaufighter crew finally put to rest
Veteran of Valour by Stephen Snelling
Hong Kong's VC Hero
UNIKOM by a serving officer
With the UN Iraq Kuwait Observer Mission
On the Fringe47
Saints and Sinners by Robert W. Gould, MBE
Bad apples in the Metropolitan Police Force
Collector's Notebook48
The Crimean War by Alexei Markarov
British and Russian Medals for the conflict


The Editorial Page5
News and View7
Market scene13
Medal Tracker52
On Parade54
Dealers' Lists56
Classified Advertising57