Why do we do it?

June 2004, Volume 42 No. 6
Why do we do it?
How many of us, I wonder, actually stop and ask ourselves why we collect coins. It's not the most logical of hobbies it it? For the collector of paintings, books, fine china, glasswear, clocks indeed a myriad of accumulation of such treasures. Books may be read, chinaa or glass displayed, paintings hung to adorn the walls of the collector's house . . . but coins? They are all too often locked away in cabinets, in drawers, in safes, even in banks-they do not add aesthetic value to their owners's house, do not add to the living environment, so what exactly is their point? On the face of it, nothing. They are, at the end of the day, simply lumps of metal that, whilst beautiful in their own way, are not in the same league as other antiques that can be displayed, showed off paraded. They are not Chippendale dressers to be admired, not Rembrandts to be wondered at-they are simply coins, everyday items the successors of which we carry around with us in our pockets and our bags-they are not objets d'art but very ordinary things that we, the numismatists choose to delight in. But why?
We are not, of course, alone in our desire to make the ordinary extraordinary. Anyone who has ever put together a selection of postcards from his hometown does exactly the same thing. Stamp collectors the world over are as guilty as we are . . . match box collectors too, as is every person ever to have accumulated a hoard of key rings, badges, napkins etc, etc., etc. But why do we do it?
The purists would, I am sure, argue that coin collectors cannot be bracketed with those whose pursuit is the acquisition of chocolate wrappers from across the globe and perhaps they would be right - there can be no doubt that the beauty of certain coins, the intricacy of the design and the sheer craftsmanship of their minting puts them more with the likes of Canaletto than Cadbury but not so with all pieces in our collections. We all have, or have had, coins in our collections which would be soundly beaten in the design and art stakes by even the dullest offerings the confectioners have come up with!
Others would state that they collect for history, a history sugar packets and badges cannot have, arguing that the fact that their coin was maybe once used by a legionnaire to buy an amphora of wine gives it some gravitas, some superiority, over certain other "collectables" and again that is a fair point. But if that is the sole reason for collecting why not by-pas the coin and go straignt for the amphora or collect amphorae too? If it's Roman history you are after why look for it just with its coins?
Personally I think we are the same as those who collect milk bottle tops or matchbooks - and just what is wrong with that? We don/t collect to have our coins on display like fine art or furniture for others to appreciate. We don't collect in order for the world to marvel at what we have managed to achieve; we don't collect to have others wonder at the intricacies of design or minting techniques (let's be honest most non-numismatists aren't THAT interested are they?). No - we collect for ourselves. We collect to get one of everything. To get the best grades we can, to find that elusive variety, that one mintmark we are missing. We collect because we want to, because we enjoy it and if that makes us more like the chocolate wrapper collectors than the gallery owners, more accumulator than expert, well I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing.

Order Back Issue

You can order this item as a back issue, simply select a delivery option from the list below and add it to your shopping basket. The price displayed is the cost of the magazine and the delivery combined.

Free Trial Issue
Click Here
Why do we do it?
Free trial issue Subscribe Buy this back issue

In This Issue

Ancients23
Cunobelin King of the Britons
Power and Prestige on his coinage
Background27
Edward II
The king who lost at Bannockburn
Insight31
Russia's Palladium coins
Strikes in exotic metal
Spotlight35
Counterfeit sovereign of GV
On the trail of a forger
On the Fringe39
Beyond the Fringe
Off beat collecting ideas
Special Offer42
A free commemorative
Send for your anniversary medal
Pioneers44
Coin collectors of the past
Three antiquaries from Essex
Tokens49
Cornish coins and tokens
Collectables from the West Country
Banknote Feature59
Bohemia and Moravia
Notes from Eastern Europe
The Collector's Page73
Collector or caretaker
Who do we think we are?

Regulars

Coin News & Views8
New Issues update14
Banknote new issues update15
Royal Mint Bulletin16
Market scene18
Bookshelf47
Price Guide to SOVEREIGNS53
Banknote news57
The Lexicon63
Letters to the Editor64
Coin Clinic64
Dealers' Lists67
Calendar69
Semi Display advertising74
The Web Page76
Classified Advertising78